Oreos: Which flavors can stay and which can go?

5. Dark Chocolate

I never thought I’d love an Oreo flavor so much. This was one of those flavors that someone brought home for me to try, and I so wish they hadn’t. This was probably one of the few flavors of Oreo that I couldn’t stop eating (besides the Original ones of course).

A lot of people I know don’t like dark chocolate, but this flavor doesn’t taste like super strong dark chocolate. It tastes almost like a mix of milk and dark chocolate with more of a hint of dark chocolate. Don’t knock this one ’til you try it; you won’t be sorry you did!

4. Peeps

What could be better than a marshmallow smashed in between two cookies? Not much, and that’s exactly what this one tasted like. It tasted like you put a Peep in between the two vanilla cookies. Peeps have that iconic flavor and color, and this flavor did not disappoint on either end of the spectrum. Although the ones I tried were bright, neon pink, I’m not sure if they came out with a variety of their classic yellow color as well.

The one thing I was missing here was those classic crystalized sugar that envelopes the normal Peeps Marshmallows. Maybe, Oreo should come out with another Peep variety and dip them in white chocolate and cover them in sugar…..

3. Birthday Cake (Golden)

This flavor comes both in the classic chocolate cookie and the vanilla golden cookie. I’ve tried both, and I have to say that I much prefer the golden cookie to the chocolate cookie. With the golden cookie, it almost gives it more of a cake batter ice cream type of flavor, which has been a favorite of mine for forever. It also comes with confetti sprinkles in it, so, what more do I need to say?

There’s really nothing bad to say about this one or anything I would change. The good thing is that this flavor never goes out of season; it’s always available and definitely one you should go ahead and try if you haven’t already.

2. Pistachio (Thins)

This is yet another flavor that I think many people never knew existed. It comes with the classic chocolate cookie, only the thins version. It is like the lemon thins, in that it is very light and goes perfectly with a nice hot cup of coffee after dinner as your dessert.

With flavors like this, it makes sense to want to smell it to see if it smells like the flavor advertises; however, it doesn’t smell super strong of pistachio, but the flavor is there for sure. Definitely find these and try them out for yourself.

1. Mint

I’m a big chocolate mint person, so obviously this one is my number one ranked favorite flavor. It’s even my favorite Blizzard flavor to get at any Dairy Queen.

It’s got a sweeter mint type of flavor that’s not too strong for kids to eat or for people who aren’t too keen on mint. These Oreos make the perfect dessert, topping for ice cream, add-ins for a milkshake, literally anything. If there’s one that you eat from this list, try these ones and make a milkshake with some vanilla ice cream; it’ll be your new go-to late night, Netflix-watching snack to have (and you won’t be sorry, you’ll be thanking me later)!

Let us know what you think of this ranking and which flavors are your favorites that we may have missed on this list down below in the comments!